The Pie Maker offers a soul-satisfying variety of hand-crafted baked goods to pair with your breakfast, lunch, or dinner. We are a small batch bakery, which means that we bake everything fresh daily. We are thrilled to see our pastry cases empty at the end of each day, because we always bake anew the following morning. Please call us a day or two ahead of time to SPECIAL ORDER items such as whole pies, bags of bagels, and any large quantity items you may want to bring home.

Our Ingredients

cortez bakeryThe Pie Maker bakes with only organic butter and natural ingredients, never using preservatives or flavor additives in any of our baked goods. We purchase cage free eggs, fruits and veggies that are often organic and locally sourced whenever we can find them. We use organic bread flour in our bagels and pate a choux. We also use locally milled, unbleached Cortez Milling 'Red Rose' flour in our cookies, cakes, and breakfast pastries. We have a dedicated blend of superfine rice flours that we use to create our fabulously tender GLUTEN FREE treats. We only brew the finest locally roasted coffee. The meat products we cook with have been raised and butchered sustainably and humanely. We think that great ingredients make great baked goods!


Cream Scones

These traditional scones are crisp on the outside, tender on the inside, and full of yummy fruit. No funny business, just mouthfuls of happiness.

Tender Fruit Muffins (GF)

Absolutely bursting with fresh fruit, our muffins boast an unprecedented moist and tender crumb that is fabulously GLUTEN FREE. Bring these home and you'll be the hostess with the mostess.

Cinnamon Rolls

Rich brioche stuffed with cinnamon and brown sugar, then glazed with a deliciously sinful icing. You'll be happy you called this breakfast.

Fruit & Nut Granola

Sweetened with apple sauce, raw Colorado honey, and a touch of brown sugar, our homemade granola has great flavor and a satisfying crunch. You'll find toasted walnuts and almonds plus dried cranberries in every bowl you pour!


cortez bakery Handmade artisan bagels created from scratch in the traditional New York style of boiling before baking. Our bagels are chewy on the outside with a soft but firm inner crumb.

Bagel Sandwich Menu

Choice Of Bagel Whipped Cream Cheese Spreads

#1 - Bagel With Butter

Choice of bagel with a generous pat of ORGANIC sweet cream butter

#2 - Egg & Cheese Bagel

Choice of bagel with stove cooked LOCAL, free-range eggs, melted Tillamook sharp cheddar, and organic butter

#3 - The Classic

Choice of bagel and cream cheese spread.

#4 - The Farmer

Choice of bagel and cream cheese spread with fresh slices of cucumber, sweet pepper, tomato, and slivered red onion

#5 - The Fisherman

Choice of bagel and cream cheese spread with Wild Alaskan Smoked Salmon, capers, fresh dill, tomato, and slivered red onion

#6 - The Wake 'N Bacon

Choice of bagel and cream cheese spread with LOCAL bacon, fresh tomato, slivered red onion, and spicy greens

Come to the Cortez Farmer's Market every Saturday morning for The Pie Maker's hot bagel sandwich stand. We will serve whipped cream cheese spreads, sweet jam and chocolate spreads, or smoked lox salmon and fresh vegetables on gourmet bagel sandwiches. See you bright and early every Saturday!


Put it in your pie-hole!

Savory Hand Pies

cortez bakery Eat with your hands! Flavorful, savory fillings wrapped in our all-butter, flaky pie crust. Try the Spinach and Feta, or the Apple, Green-Chile, and Pine-Nut, among many other scrumptious combinations. Baked to flaky on the outside, melting on the inside, and served with a side of chive-sour cream.

Sweet Pies

Rich custard or fresh fruit nestled with warm spices and tucked into our all-butter, flaky pie crust. Baked to sweet bubbling perfection. ~ Served by the slice at the bakery ~

Spring/Summer Pies

Autumn/Winter Pies

~Please call head to ask about today's flavors and availability~


Quickly becoming a new bakery favorite! Our quiche is light and fluffy, filled with chopped vegetables and local meat combinations that change daily. ~ Served by the slice at the bakery ~

*Sweet Pies or Quiche available in 9 sizes by special order with The Pie Maker. Call us at (970) 560-6039 for more information.


Large Cookies

Large enough to share but yummy enough that you may not want to! Our daily cookie offerings include: Chocolate Chip, Ginger Spice, Peanut Butter

Citrus Shortbread Cookies

cortez bakery Fun cookie shapes stuffed with organic and natural jams. Goes great with hot drinks or as an after-meal treat.

Fudge Bomb Brownies (GF)

Chock full of dark ghirardelli chocolate, these brownies are richly decadent and naturally GLUTEN FREE. Not for the faint of heart!

Coconut Macaroons (GF)

Naturally GLUTEN FREE, these cookies are delightfully crisp on the outside and mouthwateringly soft inside. We bake them for you without corn syrup because we believe that you deserve better!


Eclairs,box of Two

cortez bakery We pile extra vanilla-bean custard into these traditional french pastries, and then we smother each eclair with our rich, dark chocolate ganache. You don't have to share -- we won't tell!

Cream Puffs, box of Two

French pastry filled with a soft and billowy whipped cream and finished with fresh, juicy berries. (Seasonal). One for you, one for your friend!

Filled Chocolate Cupcakes, box of Two

Ever had a stuffed cupcake?? Need we say more.... we mix it up with creamy fillings like salted caramel, liquor-spiked ganache, or peanut butter mousse. Then each is topped with a generous serving of handmade French Buttercream.... You're welcome.

White Chocolate Cheesecake (serves 12)

This thickly sliced, New York style cheesecake is luxurious and smooth. We top our cheesecake with white chocolate ganache and swirl in fresh fruit puree for a sweet-tart combination that is utterly addictive.

Chocolate Truffle Torte (GF) (serves 12)

This dreamy, dark chocolate torte is naturally GLUTEN FREE. With its rich and indulgent fudge texture and creamy ganache topping, we have created an ultimate death-by- chocolate experience that you'll want to revisit again and again.